When you become a parent, it's not just about ensuring the safety of your little bundles of joy - it's also about helping them feel secure and comfortable. For many families, this means investing in the perfect pacifier for breastfeeding baby needs. While we can't guarantee these five will be exactly what your infant is looking for, they come highly recommended by parents who swear by their soothing powers!

Whether you're just starting out as an expecting parent or needing to switch up after trying several different options – these comfy contenders are sure to soothe even the fussiest babies into submission (for a few blissful minutes!). Read on to learn more about our top picks for keeping those little lips content.

What to Look for in Buying Pacifier for Breastfeeding Babies

When looking for the best pacifier for breastfeeding babies, you can consider the design, fit, and nipple.


When it comes to buying a pacifier for your breastfeeding baby, you may not think the design matters all that much. However, it can actually make a huge difference in keeping your little one comfortable and satisfied!

Not only should the size of the nipple fit correctly, but also the shield should be wide enough to keep your baby's cheeks away from the hard plastic edges. Additionally, if possible find something with an orthodontic pacifier's shape since this positioning of the teat in true form to a mother's breast can increase comfort and acceptance when compared to conventional pacifiers. So, don't forget - design matters when purchasing a pacifier for breastfeeding babies!


When you think about it, a baby pacifier is kind of like a shoe. If it doesn't fit right, it's going to give you blisters. The same goes for a pacifier and your baby's mouth. If the pacifier isn't the right size or shape, it can cause soreness, and discomfort, and even interfere with breastfeeding. That's why Fit is so important.

It's designed to fit comfortably in your baby's mouth, while still providing all the sucking satisfaction they need. So if you're looking for a pacifier that's comfortable for your baby and won't interrupt their breastfeeding schedule, look no further than the Fit.


When it comes to shopping for pacifiers for breastfeeding babies, the one thing that makes all the difference in nipple confusion! After all, if their mouths are used to the feeling of their mom's nipple, then it stands to reason that looking for one that gives a similar sensation is key.

Thankfully, there are a variety of nipples available so you can find one that best fits your little one's preferences and closely mimics the natural breastfeeding experience. Who knew such an important component could come down to something as small as a nipple?

How We Choose the Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Finding the best pacifier for breastfed babies isn't just a challenge, it's an adventure! Many factors come into consideration when selecting the perfect one - from the shape and size of the silicone nipples to the type of pacifier.

A breastfed newborn baby needs something a little different than formula babies, making straight pacifiers especially important for breastfed little ones. With all that in mind, we've found your baby will be absolutely smitten with their new favorite sleep-time accessory! And you can rest assured knowing that you made the perfect choice for your breastfed baby.

Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby

Best Value Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Mam silicone pacifiers provide the perfect combination of health and comfort for your newborn. The Balance Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby Pacifier is no exception, as its shape helps promote a natural tongue position and allows babies to mimic the same tongue cupping they would make while breastfeeding.

With integrated vent holes that keep skin dry and easy-grip handles, mam's silicone nipple mimics a straight pacifier for maximum comfort. Trust mam to provide your loved one with safety and functionality that is unsurpassed in its industry. Get the mam advantage today!

What You Should Know

Looking for a nursing baby human nipple? Look no further than the Evenflo Feeding Balance Pacifier Plus Stage 1 Cylindrical Baby Pacifier! This binky is designed to promote a natural tongue position, making it easier for your baby to latch on and breastfeed.

The cylindrical shape mimics the shape of a nursing nipple, helping to safeguard your breastfeeding journey. Made from 100% soft silicone, this pacifier is ultra-lightweight and flexible, reducing mouth fatigue and making it more comfortable for your baby to suck on for longer periods of time.

MAM Original Start Newborn Baby Pacifier

Best Symmetrical Shape Babies Breastfed Pacifiers

MAM Original Start Newborn Baby Pacifier

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Lost pacifiers? Not with MAM's Original Start Newborn Baby Pacifier! Developed by leading pediatric dentists and developmental psychologists, MAM's pacifiers have your baby covered with features like a SkinSoft silicone nipple to feel soft and familiar like mom and an anti-slip texture that helps the lost pacifier oft nipple stay comfortably in the baby’s mouth.

What's more, the curved shield allows the lost nature pacifier to sit comfortably on your baby’s face while small openings help air circulate and your little one’s skin to breathe freely.

What You Should Know

MAM's Original Start Pacifier provides the right pacifier soft nipple designed just right for your bundle of joy! With no right side up, this fuss-free pacifier won't need to be adjusted and fits perfectly under babies' noses.

The signature MAM pacifier design is made with BPA-free, silky SkinSoft material for a breast-like nipple shape that babies love! Plus, the self-sterilizing case makes them ideal for home and travel. The curved sterilizing shield keeps the baby comfortable, prevents moisture build-up, and keeps the baby breathing right.

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Newborn Babies 

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifiers are the go-to prevent nipple confusion pacifier brand used by medical professionals in hospitals nationwide. This particular pacifier is designed with a one-piece construction made from BPA-free, medical-grade silicone that is not only easy to clean but also supports bonding. It has a symmetrical design to respect the baby's palate, teeth and gums as they grow.

What You Should Know

When it comes to considering medical-grade silicone pacifiers for your little one, Philips AVENT is the number one choice of medical professionals! Trusting doctors and nurses across the country in hospitals nationwide, they reached for Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier to soothe and calm newborns.

Its 1 piece construction specially sized and shaped like a mother's nipple makes it perfect for babies aged 0-3 months; plus its orthodontic design respects the natural development of their teeth and gums.

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers 0-3 Month

Best Comfortable Fit Babies Breastfed Pacifiers

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers 0-3 Month

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Feed time is an essential part of the parent-child bond, and Nanobebe wants to help make it special. With tube-fed babies in mind, we designed a pacifier that takes into account all the different expressions of nourishment. Our 0 - 3 month lightweight plush pacifiers promote good oral development while remaining easy to sanitize and travel with.

You won’t need to worry about replacing them when your baby outgrows them – tube-fed baby bottle nipples fit snug inside for little ones who want a more familiar feel. So for those magical moments of connection between parent and child, trust Nanobebe to be there with something lightweight and special!

What You Should Know

Ready, set, soothe! The Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers 0-3 Months provide a rounded nipple that your baby prefers. Unlike standard pacifiers, the rounded nipple is curved comfortably around your baby’s face, nose, and chin for an ultra-comfortable fit.

It provides 100% silicone-like softness that adheres to the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines—so you know it's safe and free of BPA and Phthalate. Newborns love its skin-like feel too; designed to eliminate nipple confusion to calm and soothe breastfeeding babies with ease.

Dr. Brown's HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier 0-6m

Best Silicone Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

Dr. Brown's HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier 0-6m

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Looking for baby’s best pacifier? Look no further than Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier! This pacifier is designed specifically for babies 0-6 months, so it’s lightweight and soft enough to provide the ultimate comfort.

This one-piece construction features a contoured butterfly shape that curves away from the baby’s face, leaving plenty of room for the baby's nose and cheeks - just what young ones need! BPA-free and baby-approved, the HappyPaci will leave your baby feeling soothed in no time!

What You Should Know

Making the transition to a silicone pacifier has never been easier with Dr. Brown’s HappyPaci 100% Silicone Pacifier, designed to be the same shape as the familiar bottle nipple your baby already knows and loves. Durable, easy to clean, and aesthetically coordinated - this silicone pacifier was made for moms who want simplicity and style!

With a one-piece construction and silicone that is both dishwasher (top rack) and sterilizer safe, you can rest assured that your baby’s age is taken into consideration when it comes to the perfect silicone pacifier fit - no more silicone poking into your baby's nose! Get a 3-pack of the pacifiers in coordinating colors and keep one handy at all times.

BestValueReviews is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. BestValueReviews also participates in affiliate an program with Clickbank. We are compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies.


With so many different pacifiers sold online, it can be hard to figure out which one is the best pacifier for your breastfed infant. Look for the best baby pacifier that is non-toxic and pediatrician approved but I know there are a lot of choices still.

So we've put together a comprehensive list of the most frequently asked questions about the best pacifier for breastfeeding babies so you can make an informed decision when selecting the perfect one for your carpet.

Are pacifiers OK for breastfeeding babies?

Pacifiers are a teething baby's best friend, so why not make them an asset when breastfeeding too? For breastfed babies, the best pacifiers to choose are those that resemble natural pacifiers, such as the mom's nipple or finger.

Look for shapes that closely resemble the shape of your own nipple and use a pacifier clip to keep it close by at all times. With the right tool for teething, you can keep your baby happy, healthy, and safe.

What pacifier shapes like a boob?

When pacifier clips were first invented, they only featured generic shapes like circles and stars. However, the pacifier industry has since taken a big step forward by introducing pacifier clips designed in nipple shapes!

These pacifier clips create a more natural feel for babies and help them transition more easily from breastfeeding to pacifier use. Not only that, but they look incredibly clever - especially when paired up with pacifiers shaped like tiny mouths! With pacifier clips in shapes that look like boobs, parents can have fun spicing up their baby's pacifier needs!

What pacifier do doctors recommend?

We all know parents want the best for their baby, so why not get a pacifier that is doctor recommended? Enter the 'Cutie Pat Pacifier', made with a BPA-free silicone boy to keep your little boy comfortable and safe.

Its ergonomic shape curves just right, providing much-needed comfort in stressful times. With convenience and safety combined, it comes as no surprise that doctors are raving about this pacifier. Helping you take care of the cutest cutie pat out there!

Why do pediatricians not recommend pacifiers?

Pediatricians don't often recommend pacifiers - and certainly not for choking hazard-prone toddlers! Not to mention, a baby girl's pacifier isn't always the most attractive accessory. After all, who wants to see something that looks like a satellite dish attached to their darling little face?

Thankfully, with advances in ergonomics and shape, it's possible to find pacifiers that are designed more comfortably and fit perfectly snugly into the precious curves of your little one's face.

Do pediatricians recommend pacifiers?

Pacifiers can be a great soothing tool, but they may not always be the best choice for breastfed babies. While pediatricians might recommend pacifiers, it's important to consider using them responsibly in order to avoid skin irritation and ensure healthy oral development.

It is also important to bear in mind the potential effects of nipple confusion that could arise if parents make the decision to offer a pacifier too soon into their child's breastfeeding journey.

Why do breastfed babies refuse pacifiers?

If cute pacifiers could talk, they would probably have a lot to say about the saga of getting a breastfed baby to accept them. Many moms swear by pacifiers, claiming that they help soothe their little ones and provide comfort during long stretches of sleep.

But just when you think all hope is lost, your little one turns down the pacifier. That’s because the shape and design of most pacifiers don’t suit a baby’s teeth properly. It can also be uncomfortable for them as their teeth emerge too - making it harder for babies to get used to pacifiers without feeling some kind of discomfort.

Can a newborn sleep with a pacifier?

If your newborn is a breastfeeding champ, congratulations! Bringing healthy sucking skills to their pacifier experience can be challenging for new babies, but mam pacifiers may be the perfect way to get them going.

It can be a tricky business to know when or if you should let a newborn sleep with one though. After all, healthy habits start from day one! With mam's unique ortho-functional shield and easy-grip design, however, you can rest assured that your little one will have the best nighttime comfort around. Sleep tight!

Do pacifiers cause gas?

If you've ever searched the internet for answers to questions such as "Do pacifiers cause gas in breastfed babies?" then you know that the answer isn't so black and white. For newborns, pacifiers aren’t advised at all, but for rounded-nipple pacifiers designed for infants over three months old, some mothers use them for certain situations.

The general consensus is that using a rounded-nipple pacifier can help older babies cope better if separated temporarily from their mothers when breastfeeding.

Should I remove the pacifier once the baby is asleep?

Using a pacifier can be beneficial for babies in soothing them, but should we leave the pop pacifier shield on for too long? Research suggests that prolonged pacifier use could lead to future dental problems like misalignments and gaps.

The answer is simple - remove the pop pacifier once your baby falls asleep! Making this a part of your nighttime routine will help avoid any potential issues down the line while ensuring a happy, calming sleeping experience for your little one.

Can I give my 3-day-old a pacifier?

If you're a parent asking if it's OK to give your 3-day-old a pacifier, human evolution suggests you look no further. Did you know babies are born with a natural sucking reflex and seek out the human nipple for nutrition?

So it makes sense that human fussy babies seem to prefer a rounded pacifier nipple shape - which is appropriately designed to emulate our own! Go ahead and enjoy the brief respite these handy contraptions provide.


When it comes to finding the best pacifier for breastfed babies, it can be overwhelming. There are so many factors to consider such as sudden infant death syndrome prevention, BPA-free materials, and products designed to comfort teething babies. Thankfully, securing the perfect pacifier is just a matter of selecting one with these key criteria!

As an added bonus when purchasing a pacifier clip, you'll keep your baby's favorite accessory firmly in place – win-win! Just remember this golden rule; always make sure your baby's pacifier is safe, comfortable, and meets your expectations. Now that you know what to look for in a pacifier you'll have no problem finding the perfect one for your little sweetheart.