Ah, the binky. The magical little soother that is a parentally sanctioned godsend for when you just can’t get your baby to stop fussing.

But what if you have a breastfed infant? Different rules apply, and we are here to help!

Put down the circular silicone pacifier on a plastic stick and put away your worries; finding the best pacifiers for breastfed babies doesn't have to be complicated.

With our helpful tips, we will unravel all of the mysteries involved in choosing the right binkies for breastfed babies!

Benefits and Types of Binkies for Breastfed Babies

When it comes to binkies and breastfed babies, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. But if you want to give your little one the best chance of enjoying their binky without interrupting their breastfeeding sessions, you'll want to find the right fit!

Why do parents consider using a pacifier?

Pacifiers can provide comfort and can be used as a distraction during times when newborn babies are fussy. They may also help decrease the risk of SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). This doesn't mean that giving your baby a pacifier is always necessary or recommended; use your judgment and talk to your doctor about what would work best for you!

Now that we know why parents might want to use them, what kind should they choose?

When choosing a binky, it must fit in with the baby’s feeding routine; especially if you’re nursing. This means looking for things like design features meant for breastfed babies specifically. There are plenty of great options out there – here are some characteristics to look for:

BPA-Free Nipples

The best pacifier is a BPA-free pacifier. You don’t want to introduce any toxins to your baby through their binky.

Orthodontic Shape

It’s also important that they have an orthodontic shape that encourages proper jaw development while still promoting the natural sucking motions associated with breastfeeding.

No Internal Parts

You won’t need any internal pieces that could come loose or even fall out altogether, making them very easy on momma bear too!

Soft Shields

The softer shields will be better for breastfeeding babies because they're more comfortable when held up against mommy's chest during feedings compared to the harder plastic ones, which can dig into her skin and cause discomfort—something nobody wants!

Multiple Sizes Availability

Since growing is inevitable, having multiple sizes available allows moms and dads some flexibility as well as longevity with each particular product line, so those beloved binkies stick around longer than just one week or two months.

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers

Best Binkies with Face Contouring for Breastfed Babies

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Soft like Mom's hug, this 100% flexible silicone pacifier gives the baby a soothing sensation that is truly as comforting and natural as it gets.

With its snug-fit design, you can be sure your little one has a secure sleep no matter what position they take on. It keeps the baby's face unobstructed, so all of those cute snooze faces are still visible!

Let your little one snooze soundly with this BPA-free silicone pacifier, designed to keep them cozy and secure. It's recommended by pediatricians for its one-piece design free of phthalates, latex, lead, and PVC—just the great sleep they need!

What You Should Know

Nanobebe Baby Pacifiers not only have a unique curve that fits comfortably with your baby's nose and chin, but they also have a one-piece construction, so bubbling away in the dishwasher or sterilizer is super simple.

So no more struggling to reach those difficult-to-clean crevices!

With our extensive range of vibrant colors, you can be sure to find the perfect binky for your little one! Whether they're newborn babies or walking toddlers, Nanobee has an option that'll suit every 0-36-month-old.

The First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers

Best Binkies for Breastfed Newborns

The First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

The perfect solution for a breastfed newborn baby's needs: the First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers!

With this silicone pacifier, you can help your newborn baby ease into blissful slumber while keeping the baby's nose safe.

Trusted by hospitals for years, these gumdrop pacifiers offer a one-piece design and unique contoured shape. It is latex-free with a lightweight silicone pacifier construction that's easy for your little one to manage.

Outfit your newest family member in gumdrop pacifiers today and start soothing everyone in hearing range!

What You Should Know

Available in two vibrant colors, pink and purple, these are one of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies that'll give them the comfort they crave.

The most exciting feature? They work with most pacifier clips, so you don't have to worry about constantly purchasing new ones! As far as modern-day necessities go, the First Years Gumdrop Newborn Pacifiers are an absolute parent must-have.

Evenflo Feeding Balance Pacifier

Best Binkies for Breastfed Teething Babies

Evenflo Feeding Balance Pacifier

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Give your little one the best of both worlds: a pacifier that's not only convenient to use, but also beneficial for their oral development!

With Balance Plus Orthodontic Pacifiers, teething babes will get soothing support and an orthodontic shape perfect for helping those teeth emerge in no time.

Not only is it designed to provide a breast-like shape that won’t cause nipple confusion, but it's also made with a curved faceplate to fit right in the baby’s mouth. With its one-piece soft silicone nipple design that’s flexible and lightweight and integrated vent holes for keeping skin dry, it makes sure that your little one stays comfortable for longer periods.

What You Should Know

With Evenflo pacifiers, you can rest assured that your baby's safety and health are always a priority. Its 100% BPA-free, Polycarbonate, PVC, and Phthalates free pacifiers are made of FDA-approved food-grade material.

These high-quality designs boast an easy grip handle to make sure both parents and little ones get lasting comfort with every use - just in time for those priceless 'Evenflo moments'!

NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers

Best Orthodontic Binkies for Breastfed Babies

NUK Comfy Orthodontic Pacifiers

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

For over six decades, NUK orthodontic pacifiers have been the go-to for parents looking to mimic a mom's natural nipple shape.

Invented by a team of pediatric experts and modeled after actual breast nipples, this orthodontic pacifier with a classic design helps babies easily switch between breastfeeding and using the pacifier!

Keep your little one breathing easy—and look cute! With the NUK heart-shaped shield, the baby's face will stay safe from scratches thanks to its 100% gentle silicone construction. The cuddly, contoured shape fits perfectly under your baby's nose for comfortable snoozing all night long.

What You Should Know

Say goodbye to tiny, hard-to-clean pacifiers and hello to sanitary storage!

The 3-pack of orthodontic pacifiers by NUK is BPA-free and provides the perfect fit for your baby aged 0–6 months. And with our easy microwave cleaning feature and top-rack dishwasher safety, you'll be sure to keep them spick and span.

So you can keep up those stress-free smiles on both ends of the equation!

Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier

Best Multi-Purpose Binkies for Breastfed Babies

Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier 

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

The Ryan & Rose Cutie PAT Pacifier Teether is the perfect choice for your teething baby!

This clever combo design provides both a pacifier and a teething toy, so you don't have to choose between comfort and safety. With its 100% medical-grade silicone construction, it's backed by science, not sorcery, when soothing that gummy grin!

What You Should Know

Little ones can relax and feel secure with the soft bulb-shaped BPA-free silicone nipple of this baby pacifier!

It mimics breastfeeding for natural palate development, plus its durable material is top-rack dishwasher safe! No more worries about how comfy your munchkin will be—soothing comfort has never been so easy.

Treat your baby to some stylish fun with these silicone pacifiers! Choose from an array of bright and bold colors designed especially for the fashionable little ones in your life.

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier

Best Hygienic Binkies for Breastfed Babies

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

The Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier is so light it practically floats, allowing little ones to stay calm and content for longer. It's perfectly designed to never overload your baby's mouth!

With this clever medical-grade silicone baglet, you can rest easy knowing that no matter which way it is put in the baby's mouth, this pacifier is always installed correctly. So goodbye worries, and hello peace of mind!

Babies can breathe easily with the comfy, curved pacifier shield that sits comfortably between their chin and nose. Plus, the extra airflow from the holes on each side helps to keep irritation at bay, so the baby’s skin stays snug as a bug!

What You Should Know

Looking for something stylish, hygienic, and easy to clean?

Tommee Tippee's range of silicone pacifiers comes in a selection of color options that look great while being smooth as silk - the perfect combination!

Wipe away dust and bacteria with ease thanks to its anti-static properties. The best part is you don't even need fancy cleaning methods: just pop it in your dishwasher or sterilizer, et voilà, sparkling shine guaranteed!

Smily Mia Penguin Buddy

Best Wearable Binkies for Breastfed Babies

Smily Mia Penguin Buddy

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love It

Looking for something special to soothe your teething baby? Look no further than this one-of-a-kind teething pacifier! Many breastfed babies refuse normal pacifiers, but surely they'll love this one, as it works like a boob and a regular 'dummy' simultaneously.

You never have to worry about collecting dirt or hair off of dropped pacis again – just slip on their wrist and they're good to go! Your little one can grasp onto this reindeer's stem and use their impressive sense of direction to seamlessly locate the nipple for soothing relief.

For teething babies, elastic silicone helps them nibble away at distractions in no time!

What You Should Know

Say goodbye to sucking and chewing habits with the Penguin Buddy—a pediatrician-recommended solution perfect for little hands!

Not only does it encourage motor skill development, but it's BPA-free, and made of food-grade silicone.

It's cinch to clean because it's dishwasher and freezer safe. Now that's what we call convenience!

10 Infant Toys That Will Keep Babies Entertained For Hours!
Tired of hearing your baby cry? Check out our list of the 10 best infant toys to keep them entertained! From squeaky ducks to rattles, we’ve got you covered!

Hi there! Are you a parent or baby lover looking to make some extra passive income? With this amazing opportunity, you can get paid simply by talking about the wonderful world of baby items! Just click below and find out how you can turn your passion into a profitable side hustle using AI. Don't miss out on this incredible chance to make some extra money with something so close to your heart. Click now and start sharing the joys of baby items today!

BestValueReviews is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. BestValueReviews also participates in an affiliate program with Clickbank. We are compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies.


Finding the perfect binky doesn't have to be an arduous task, nor has it taken over precious time spent bonding with tiny humans. But knowing what characteristics will yield success helps sort through choices quickly, so moms and dads can get back to doing what really matters most: providing safe, uninterrupted snuggles and cuddles whenever desired!

To make things easier, let us share some frequently asked questions from other moms who have gone through this journey before you.

What are the benefits of using a pacifier for breastfed babies?

Breastfed babies tend to have a strong urge to suck, and the best pacifier can be a great way to satisfy this urge without having to feed them constantly. Pacifiers can also have a calming effect on fussy babies and help them fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer.

Additionally, pacifiers have been linked to a reduced risk of SIDS when used during sleep, as the sucking motion can help keep the airway open and reduce the risk of suffocation. Overall, pacifiers can be a helpful tool for parents to soothe and comfort their breastfed babies, while also providing potential health benefits.

Can using a pacifier interfere with breastfeeding?

Some mothers may find it difficult to meet their babies' frequent need to suck, which can lead to nipple soreness or discomfort. Using the best pacifier can help satisfy a baby's natural sucking reflex, which can reduce nipple confusion and make it easier for babies to latch onto the breast.

Additionally, pacifiers can help prevent babies from using their mothers' nipples as a comfort source, which can lead to painful nursing sessions. While there is some concern that pacifiers can interfere with breastfeeding, many experts believe that when used correctly, pacifiers can actually help facilitate breastfeeding by making it more comfortable for both mom and baby.

Therefore, if you are a breastfeeding mom, it is worth considering using only the best pacifier to help soothe and comfort your baby.

When should I introduce a pacifier to my breastfed baby?

Even the best pacifier when introduced too early can interfere with breastfeeding and cause nipple confusion, which can lead to difficulty latching and low milk supply. As such, it is generally recommended to wait until breastfeeding is well established before introducing a pacifier, which typically occurs around 3–4 weeks of age.

However, there may be situations where introducing a pacifier earlier can be beneficial, particularly if your baby is fussy or has difficulty sleeping. In these cases, it is important to choose a pacifier that is designed for breastfed babies, as these tend to have a nipple shape that closely resembles the breast and can help prevent nipple confusion.

Ultimately, the decision to introduce a pacifier to your breastfed baby should be based on your baby's individual needs and your own comfort level with using one. If you have any concerns, it is always a good idea to consult with your pediatrician or lactation consultant for guidance.

How often should I clean my baby's pacifier?

Even the best pacifiers need to be regularly cleaned to prevent the buildup of bacteria and germs that can cause infections or illness. Washing your baby's pacifier with soap and water after each use is the first step to keeping it clean.

Additionally, boiling the pacifier in water for a few minutes at least once a week can help sterilize it and kill any remaining bacteria. It is also a good idea to inspect the pacifier regularly for signs of wear and tear and to replace it as needed to ensure that your baby is using a clean and safe pacifier at all times.

Is it safe to let my baby sleep with a pacifier?

Yes, it is generally safe to let your baby sleep with a pacifier. In fact, using one o the best pacifiers we recommended during sleep has been shown to reduce the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

However, if your baby is under six months old and not yet able to roll over, it's important to place them to sleep on their back with no objects in the crib, including pacifiers.

And if your baby is a heavy sleeper or has a tendency to pull the pacifier out of your baby's mouth during sleep, it may be best to wait until they are older and more able to manage the pacifier themselves.

As always, it's important to consult with your pediatrician for recommendations on the best pacifiers for breastfed babies.

Can pacifier usage lead to dental issues?

Even the best pacifiers that are prolonged use can have negative effects on a child's developing baby's mouth and teeth. According to the American Dental Association, frequent and prolonged use of a pacifier beyond the age of two can cause dental problems, such as an overbite or misaligned teeth.

This is because the constant pressure of the pacifier on the teeth and jaw can cause them to shift and become misaligned. However, most children who stop using a pacifier before the age of two do not experience these dental problems.

It is recommended that parents limit the use of a pacifier and begin to wean their child off of it around six months of age, as this is when a child's natural sucking reflex typically begins to decrease.

Additionally, parents should ensure that the pacifier they choose is appropriate for their child's age and development, as using a pacifier that is too small or too large can also cause dental problems.

How do I choose the right size pacifier for my baby?

It is important to follow the manufacturer's guidelines when choosing the right size for your baby. Some pacifiers for breastfed babies are also designed specifically for certain age ranges or stages of development, such as those with smaller or larger nipples to accommodate different feeding needs.

If you are unsure about which size or type of pacifier to choose for your baby, consult with your pediatrician or a lactation consultant for guidance in finding the best pacifiers for your baby.

Can a pacifier cause my baby to choke?

Using a pacifier carries a low risk of choking, but even the best pacifiers for breastfed babies can be of risk. So parents should always supervise their baby while they use one to prevent any accidents from occurring.

It's also important to choose the right size and shape of a pacifier for your baby's age and development level to prevent any potential issues.

If you notice that your baby is having difficulty using their pacifier or is gagging frequently, it may be time to switch to a different size or shape. Also, inspect your baby's pacifier regularly to ensure that it is not damaged or worn, as this can also increase the risk of choking from a torn pacifier.

How do I wean my baby off their pacifier?

It is important to note that weaning a baby off a pacifier should be done gradually and with patience. Abruptly taking away a pacifier can be upsetting for a baby and may lead to resistance.

Some parents find it helpful to start by limiting pacifier use to certain times of day or activities, such as only during naps or bedtime. As the baby becomes more comfortable with this, the parent can gradually reduce the amount of time the pacifier is used.

Offering alternative sources of comfort, such as a favorite stuffed animal or blanket, can also help make the transition easier. Parents can also use positive reinforcement, such as praise or rewards, when the baby goes without the pacifier for a certain time.

It is important to remember that every baby is different, and the weaning process may take longer for some than others.


After all the research and consideration, finding the best pacifiers for breastfed babies can be a game-changer. Not only can it soothe a fussy baby and promote better sleep, but it can also reduce the risk of SIDS.

With our top picks and helpful tips, you'll be sure to find the perfect pacifier for your little one.

So don't wait; click the button "check price on Amazon" to shop today and give your baby the comfort they deserve!